Deals & Cases
DR & AJU Successfully Defends the President of a Company Accused of Aiding and Abetting a Duplicate Meat Loan
In a case where the president of Company D conspired with a bonded refrigeration warehouse operator to secure loans from financial institutions by collateralizing imported frozen meats in duplicate, the executive of Company C (“Client”) was accused of aiding and abetting a violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud) by purchasing meat owned by Company D on paper without actual purchase and then using it as collateral. DR & AJU represented the Client and successfully obtained a not-guilty verdict in the first trial.
DR & AJU effectively argued for the Client’s innocence at the first trial, presenting the following claims: (i) To establish aiding and abetting, the offender must have the intent to commit the aiding and abetting as well as the intention of the principal offender. Since Client was unaware of the president of Company D’s providing duplicate collateral to financial institutions, Client had no intention of the principal offender; (ii) Since financial institutions do not consider whether the ownership of collateral is on the loan applicant or a third party as a significant factor to consider when determining whether to grant a loan as long as the security rights were acquired validly, it is hard to consider that the Client’s purchase of the meat on paper as defrauding.
This case sets a significant precedent for similar cases, since it not only clarifies that the intention of the principal offender is a crucial condition for establishing aiding and abetting, but also prevents indiscriminate indictments that consider factors irrelevant to the determination of a mortgage loan execution as aiding and abetting of defrauding.